ARCOLA, Ill. -- The bright blue logo on the sign in front of Kauffman Amish Furniture Outlet signifies a new destination for shoppers looking for locally made products in Illinois’ Amish Country.

The Amish Craft Barn in Seaford has helped beautify homes across Long Island with custom furnishings for three decades. And it all started with a young couple’s road trip. This spring, owners Pam and ...